How Brexit bid-up bankers' pay in the EU
If you're asked to leave London for a financial services job in the European Union, it seems reasonable to assume you'll take a pay cut. After all, data from the European Banking Authority on the number of people working in finance and earning seven figures in the UK versus the whole of the European Union, regularly shows that there are more than twice as many in London than the whole of the EU. And high pay at the top percolates down.
However, as banks have shifted staff out of London following Brexit, there's evidence that EU pay has been hiked. In Germany, for example, nearly 550 in finance people earned €1m or more in 2020, up from 390 in 2017.
Last week's court judgement concerning Zhuofang Wei, a Princeton and Stanford graduate, who worked in strategy for Canadian bank CIBC in London, shed some light on the dynamic through which pay has been bid-upwards.
Working in London in 2019, Wei was paid £247k in total compensation in her role as a CRO, which amounted to €286k euros under the then-exchange rate.
CIBC planned to move her to Luxembourg for a new combined CRO and COO role. Using benchmarked data from McLagan, the bank determined that average pay for a head of risk in Luxembourg was €253k and that average pay for a chief operating officer in the Duchy was anything from €225k to 350k. CIBC could conceivably, therefore, have cut Wei's pay by around €30k in Luxembourg (although it could also conceivably have increased it to the €300k- €400k a headhunter said it could cost to find someone externally).
Instead, of cutting pay to the lowest possible level, however, CIBC was prepared to pay Wei €206k in salary, plus €117k in bonus. This would have resulted in total compensation of €323k.
Wei left the bank before taking the new role. But she wasn't the only CIBC banker to receive an offer more generous than might otherwise have been the case. The court notes indicate that Thomas Pellequer, the chief executive of CIBC Capital Markets in Luxembourg was offered target compensation of €1,025,000 to move to Luxembourg from London in May 2020. This was despite the fact that it was more than double the amount a Luxembourg recruiter said was required to fill the role. It was also on the 75th percentile of CEO pay in Luxembourg according to McLagan. When Pellequer was initially offered a salary below his London base, he reportedly expressed his great unhappiness and said he'd take a few weeks to consider the offer. CIBC then made amends (by increasing his salary and reducing his role-based allowance).
The fundamental issue seems to be that CIBC - like most banks - couldn't persuade its staff to move unless it compensated them at least on a par with London. And in addition to London-level pay, it was compelled to offer a relocation allowance.
While Brexit has therefore been a headache for EU banks trying to keep pace with pay for incomers, it's been much better news for bankers themselves. They've often transferred to cities with lower costs of living, but been paid the same or more than in London. With the pound potentially set to drop further against the euro under the new government of Liz Truss, this may be something to keep in mind.
Have a confidential story, tip, or comment you’d like to share? Contact: firstname.lastname@example.org in the first instance. Whatsapp/Signal/Telegram also available (Telegram: @SarahButcher)
Bear with us if you leave a comment at the bottom of this article: all our comments are moderated by human beings. Sometimes these humans might be asleep, or away from their desks, so it may take a while for your comment to appear. Eventually it will – unless it’s offensive or libelous (in which case it won’t.)